Op-ed

Israel's Security Agencies Must Not Be Used for Political Ends

| Written By:

Recent news reports allege attempts to use Israel's police and Shin Bet for political ends around the election, underscoring the importance of independent oversight and legal guardrails, and the dangers of recent legislation weakening these safeguards.

Photo by Olivier Fitoussi/POOL

Israel's vaunted security agencies play a vital role in keeping a country with innumerable external and internal threats safe. But at the same time, security agencies that possess unprecedented powers must also be restrained. In a democracy, this is first and foremost the role of the elected officials serving as the representatives of the people. But this is not enough on its own. After all, elected leaders are also politicians who may seek to exploit their authority over the agencies for their own electoral objectives. To counter this temptation, a democracy also needs clear laws and independent agencies tasked with safeguarding the rights of the people and keeping security agencies in check. In this regard, legislation passed in the last Knesset took Israel in the wrong direction and should be amended to face the real challenges facing our democracy. Recent news reports have alleged efforts by the political players to undermine the results of the October 27 election, using Israel's security apparatus. One report alleges that a political operative in the Prime Minister's Office provided potentially misleading evidence to the police, directing them to arrest three Bedouin activists for the Arab Ra'am party, claiming there was evidence of efforts to pay Arab voters to boost turnout. This has led to a probe by Israel's attorney general into whether a pre-planned effort occurred to undermine the legitimacy of the election. Another report claimed that Shin Bet Chief David Zini sought to wiretap five Arab lawmakers for alleged foreign interference – which was made public by Mr. Zini two days after the election – without sufficient evidence. It goes without saying that if any of the revelations are correct, a comprehensive examination of the conduct of the police and Shin Bet on and near Election Day is essential. We must establish exactly what happened, who initiated these actions, who ordered them, and the professional and legal grounds on which they were based. This is necessary even if we assume that the police officers and Shin Bet personnel involved believed they were simply carrying out their duties. But this incident is yet another reminder that oversight of the security agencies by elected officials is insufficient on its own. In Israel, the police and Shin Bet possess extensive powers, including the authority to detain individuals, conduct surveillance, and collect information about citizens. Existing legal norms seek to guard against the danger that these powers will be exploited or deployed for political ends. For example: Section 4 of the Shin Bet Law expressly prohibits assigning the agency tasks intended to advance partisan political interests. Yet this safeguard depends largely on the attitude of the head of the Shin Bet, who has a duty to refuse improper political demands. The Israel Police commissioner likewise has a duty to exercise the organization's powers impartially and in the public interest. But when the heads of these agencies cooperate with political leaders, or fail to recognize the impropriety of their directives, these internal safeguards may fail. In such circumstances, external oversight of the security agencies becomes an essential safeguard. The attorney general can prevent the misuse of the Shin Bet's powers, as she reportedly did when the agency sought to wiretap members of the Knesset. The Department of Internal Police Investigations can investigate suspected criminal offenses committed by police officers, even when senior police officials are implicated. And in appropriate cases, intervention by the courts may also be necessary. This is where the dangerous implications of legislation passed by the Knesset over the last year that weakens oversight become clear. The law weakening the status of the attorney general, scheduled to take effect in January 2027, curtails the agency's oversight powers and makes it relatively simple for elected politicians to remove its chief from office. The government could then replace an independent attorney general with one more amenable to the whims of the politicians who appointed them. The law concerning the Department of Internal Police Investigations, passed in June and whose implementation has been partially stayed by the courts, seeks to separate the department from the State Attorney's Office and give politically connected individuals influence over the appointment of its director. The result could be the obstruction of investigations into the political misuse of the police. The recent revelations, insofar as they are accurate, illustrate just how dangerous it is to weaken the independence of the attorney general, the Department of Internal Police Investigations, and the courts. The legislative amendments affecting these institutions create the risk of concentrating political power in the hands of those who direct Israel's internal security agencies, while weakening the mechanisms intended to prevent the abuse of that power. There is no doubt that Israel could benefit from reforms to its legal and judicial systems, but weakening the powers of legal and judicial oversight—one of the very few checks on government power in Israel—is dangerous. On the contrary, the independence of these institutions is vital for Israeli democracy and must be safeguarded. Otherwise, the next time there is an attempt to use the police or Shin Bet for political purposes, we may discover that there is no longer an independent authority capable of stopping, or even investigating, such actions.

A version of this op-ed was published in The Times of Israel.